Actuarial Notes

Multi-State Model

A Multi-State Model describes an individual moving among a finite set of states — for example healthy, disabled and dead — with transitions governed by a Markov Chain; benefits and premiums attach to being in a state or to moving between states. The two-state alive–dead Survival Model is its simplest case.

\text{APV} = \sum_{k=1}^{n} b\, v^{k}\, P_{ij}^{\,k}

P(X_1 = \cdots = X_n = i \mid X_0 = i) = (P_{ii})^{n}

  • The APV is for a benefit b payable at the end of each period k in which a life that starts in state i is in state j; v is the one-period discount factor (Present Value) and P^k_{ij} comes from the Chapman-Kolmogorov Equations.
  • A disability model typically has states H (healthy), D (disabled) and X (dead, absorbing), with transitions H \to D (disablement), D \to H (recovery) and H, D \to X.
  • Being in a state versus staying in it: P^n_{ii} counts every path that is back in i at time n, including those that left and returned; (P_{ii})^n counts only paths that never left. Waiting periods and "continuously disabled" conditions need the second.
  • Transition probabilities change with age, so realistic models are non-homogeneous — a different Transition Probability Matrix each year, multiplied in order.
  • In continuous time the matrix is replaced by transition intensities, and the force of mortality (Hazard Rate) is the intensity of the alive \to dead transition. A pair of lives (x) and (y) is another multi-state model, with four states: both alive, only (x) alive, only (y) alive, and both dead. The joint-life status fails at the first death and the last-survivor status at the last.

Two-Year Disability Probabilities Annual transitions among Healthy, Disabled and Dead are \mathbf{P} = \begin{array}{c|ccc} & H & D & X \\ \hline H & 0.85 & 0.10 & 0.05 \\ D & 0.20 & 0.65 & 0.15 \\ X & 0 & 0 & 1 \end{array} For a healthy life, find the state probabilities two years from now and the probability of staying healthy throughout.

Answer Row H of \mathbf{P}^2:

\begin{align*}
P^2_{HH} &= 0.85(0.85) + 0.10(0.20) \\
&= 0.7425 \\
P^2_{HD} &= 0.85(0.10) + 0.10(0.65) \\
&= 0.1500 \\
P^2_{HX} &= 0.85(0.05) + 0.10(0.15) + 0.05(1) \\
&= 0.1075
\end{align*}

Staying healthy throughout has probability 0.85^2 = 0.7225. The gap 0.7425 - 0.7225 = 0.02 is the path H \to D \to H, (0.10)(0.20): disabled in year 1, recovered by year 2.

Valuing a Disability Income Benefit Using the same matrix, a policy on a healthy life pays \$10{,}000 at the end of each of the next two years if the insured is then disabled. At 5\% annual interest, find the actuarial present value.

Answer The disabled probabilities are P^1_{HD} = 0.10 and P^2_{HD} = 0.15:

\begin{align*}
\text{APV} &= 10{,}000\left(\frac{0.10}{1.05} + \frac{0.15}{1.05^2}\right) \\
&= 10{,}000\,(0.095238 + 0.136054) \\
&= \$2{,}312.93
\end{align*}

The year-2 payment is worth more despite the extra discounting, because disablement accumulates faster than recovery removes it.